How to Avoid a Hiring Horror Story
August 9th, 2011As one of Central Virginia’s leading staffing agencies, we’ve heard plenty of hiring horror stories from employers over the years. It usually starts with a candidate that looks great on paper and ends with the employer being sorely disappointed. Worst-case scenarios can even wind up in the courtroom.
Some commonalities among these problem new hires include:
- Lack of a strong work ethic
- Wasting time on social networking sites
- Inadequate writing skills
- Inadequate math skills
- Inadequate communication skills
- Inability to handle constructive feedback
- Lack of critical thinking skills or creativity
To avoid these mistakes, and the ensuing horror stories, an effective hiring process is a must. Here are some ideas that can help you implement one:
Take a pro-active approach to recruiting.
Don’t just write and place an ad on a job board and then sit back and wait for the top candidates to apply. Be pro-active in your recruitment process. Reach out to your business network and let them know you’re looking. Advertise in trade journals and industry publications. And through sites liked LinkedIn, make a concerted effort to uncover hidden, passive candidates who may not necessarily be looking for a new job opportunity.
Ask the right questions.
Asking a candidate general questions about their strengths and weaknesses is perfectly acceptable. But also be sure to ask them for specific examples of their skills and personality. For instance:
“Give me an example of a goal you reached and how you achieved it”
Or:
“Tell me of an instance where you had to deal with a difficult customer and how you handled it.”
Test candidates.
During the hiring process, use aptitude testing and personality assessments in order to screen out those individuals who are not a good fit for the position and your company’s culture.
Develop job simulations.
Job simulations are certainly not necessary for every hiring decision you’ll make; but they’re a good option for testing out candidates for mission-critical positions because they can help you more accurately gauge specific job-related abilities and skills. While simulations can be costly to develop, making a hiring mistake could be far costlier in the long run.
Understand your audience.
When it comes effectively training a new hire, you need to understand your audience. For instance, younger employees aren’t going to respond to the same training methods as older workers. Therefore, be sure to employ a variety of training methods that include webinars and podcasts.
If you’re ready to hire – and would like some expert help – contact Adams & Garth. As one of Central Virginia’s leading staffing agencies, we manage all the details of the hiring process, so you can stay focused on running your business.
Our Direct Hire services include:
- Evaluating your job requirements and culture
- Developing a position description that best promotes your organization
- Sourcing the most qualified candidates through advertising, online job postings, and direct recruitment
- Screening, interviewing, and skills testing potential candidates
- Conducting reference, background, and DMV checks as well as drug testing
- Coordinating the interview process
- Acting as your liaison in negotiating the offer

